Small House of Everything

Small House of Everything

Thursday, November 19, 2026

FORGOTTEN BOOK: THE MONSTER OF FLORENCE

The Monster of Florence:  A True Story by Douglas Preston & Mario Spezi  (first published in Italy as Dolce Colline di Sangue, 2006, in which Spezi did most of the writing; revised and expanded in English by Preston, 2008)

Between 1968 and 1985, a series of horrid murders were committed around the city of Florence in the Italian region of Tuscany.  In Italy, many men live with their parents until they get married, and one result is that couples often have sex in their cars on deserted roads and Lovers' Lanes; this also prompts many men to voyeurism at these sights.  Now couples are being killed in their cars while having -- or just after -- sex, shot, with the female's nude body being dragged from the car and, most often, with her genitals removed.  Later female victims would have the left breast torn off; in one case a thick grape vine had been thrust into the victim's vagina.  Forensic evidence showed that the same .22 caliber handgun was used in all the murders, going back to 1961 when an unfaithful wife was killed by her husband.

It took a resourceful crime reporter, Mario Spezi, to tie many of the murders together.  It was Spezi who dubbed the killer (or killers) Il Mostro di Firenze, "The Monster of Florence."  Over the years, the investigation was marked by incompetence, corruption, political ambition, professional jealousy, pigheadedness, and sheer stupidity, aided by the fact that the case was being investigated by two opposing sides -- the polizia and the carabinieri; in theory the two would work together, although in reality each would often have its own agenda.  In this particular turf battel, one side held to the Sardinian Trail theory which held that the murders were linked to a group of Sardinians associated with the 1961 "honor killing" murder and that the murder weapon had been passed to an unknown person who later used it in the recent killings; the other side felt that the murders were part of a vast conspiracy linking powerful men (and later, satanic rituals).  The latter side won the argument and the Sardinian Trail was dismissed as a false lead.  Over the years, the theories grew wilder and wilder, ignored obvious facts, and buried any clues that might overturn the theory.  Arrests were made, trials held, people released, and many lives ruined.  Obvious suicides were later declare to be murders, with no proof.  In one case, it was believed that a suicide's body had been replaced and then dug up and the real victim placed back in the grave years afterward.  Mental defectives and people kin the lowest depths of alcoholism were trotted forth as reliable witnesses.  If the stakes were not so high, it would be laughable.  

Enter thriller writer Douglas Preston, who moved to Florence with his family in 2000.  Preston met and became good friends with Mario Spezi.  He shortly learned that on of the murders had taken place not far from where he and his family were staying.  He became fascinated with the murders, and soon he and Spezi were continuing the investigation with the possibility of a New Yorker article.  (The article was scheduled to appear in September 2001, but was pulled after the World Trade Center attacks; the two then decided put their research into a book.)  Spezi was dogged and unafraid, publicly calling attention to the failure of the police and judicial officials.  In Italy, where saving face is utmost, that was a mistake.  Eventually Spezi was arrested on hidden charges, which basically amounted to he, in reporting, was hampering a criminal investigation.  Eventually, officials charged him with actual involvement in the murders!  Preston was called in for interrogation, where he was accused of perjury when he did not respond the way officials wanted him to.  He was told to leave the country and that he would be arrested if he ever returned.

Preston used his influence to organize protests from a number of author's groups and other parties.  Soon, international attention was placed on Spezi's case and the absolute lack of evidence behind it.  Jiustice moves slowly but eventually Spezi was released, and the two most involved in persecuting him were admonished.  One, the public prosecutor, would go on to use much of the same specious reasoning to charge Amanda Knox with the murder of British student Meredith Kercher in Perugia.

The last person to be charged in the Monster of Florence killings was likely to be acquitted at the time the book was published.  (He was.)   Preston remains ;persona indagata in Italy for a series of crimes "that are still, more or less, under judicial seal and secret."  He has also been denounced before the  Tribunal of Lecco (a city in the north of Italy) "for difammazione a mezzo stampa, defamation through means of the press, a criminal charge."  The name of his accuser and the specifics of the charge were omitted from the official document.  The Monster of Florence has never been identifed, and most likely never will be.

This was a fascinating  book, with the first half detailing the crimes, the official investigation. and Spezi's involvement.  The second half begins with Preston's arrival in France, and includes his work with Spezi, and, finally, the attempts to silence Spezi and Preston.  Along the way we get an intimate look at the beauties of Florence and the kindness of its people, as well as the horrors inherent in a society where pride rules all.  It is a fast and detailed read, and is highly recommended.

In my previous life, for my sins, I was a reporter.  The thing that a reporter absolutely does not want to do is insert himself into a story.  In this case, Preston had no choice.

1 comment:

  1. I just ordered this book after reading your intriguing review! This sounds like a fascinating story!

    ReplyDelete