"The Lady from Yesterday" by Jeremiah Healy (published in the MWA anthology Blood on their Hands, edited by Lawrence Block, 2003)
Jeremiah Healy (1948-2014) was a lawyer, academic, and crime novelist best known for his character John Francis Cuddy, a Boston private investigator. As "Terry Devane," he also penned three legal thrillers and one short story featuring defense attorney Mairead O'Clair. "The Lady from Yesterday" is one of at least three short stories to feature Lauderdale "tennis bum" and private eye Rory Calhoun, (whose mother had a thing for the mid-20th century actor).
Calhoun is approached at the Lauderdale Tennis Club by Monica Lewis, an veteran exotic dancer whose career is on the downswing due to age and gravity. Monica is the primary suspect in the murder of Tara "T.N.T." Tate, an up-and-coming dancer at the Cottontails, the "gentleman's club" where both worked. The night before Tara was killed, she and Monica had gotten into an argument, during which Tara had scratched Monica on the arm, leaving Monica's DNA under her fingernails. That, plus the fact that Tara was bucking for the top spot at the club, replacing Monica, provided enough motive to convince the incompetent detective in charge of the case that Monica was guilty. Monica wanted Rory to investigate and prove that she did not murder Tara. Rory felt uneasy because it was still an open case with the police and turned Monica down.
The following day, the newspaper headline read SECOND DANCER'S DEATH SOLVES FIRST. Monica was presumed to have hung herself either out of guilt, or because the police were closing in. Rory went to see the cop in charge, who was all too willing to have everything tied up in a nice, neat package. Because of his own feeling of guilt, Rory decides to investigate.
After talking with Rocky, the hard-shelled female owner/manager of Cottontails, Rory up with three people he wanted to talk to: "The Professor," a steady customer who would come not just to ogle, but to stare at Tara; Lacey Peevers, another dancer at the club, who would most likely taken over Monica's spot if Tara had not arrived on the scene; and Tara's husband, Barry Cardiff, who did not want Tara dancing at all, resented when she went on tour throughout the South, and had to stay at home taking care of his invalid mother while Tara was off shaking her booty. Rocky also told Rory that Tara was saving every bit of money she could to build a nest egg and retire from the business and that Tare had told she had almost accrued enough money for that purpose.
The Professor turned out to be Jason Nolan, an English teacher at the local college, and who claimed to appreciate exotic dance as an art form and quoted various works of literature to prove his point. He told Rory that he suspected Tara's murderer was actually Lacey Peevers.
Lacy Peevers turned out to be a young mother devoted more to her infant son than to her dance career. She suspected the Professor.
Barry Cardiff was a man who, despite everything, still loved his wife. He suspected that Tara was having affairs while she was on the road -- sometimes for a month or more -- and that he had recently learned that Tara was turning tricks and filming herself with unsuspecting men for blackmail; he gave Rory a recording marked TARA DOES FRANK that he had found hidden in her bureau after she had been killed. Cardiff also resented that Tara refused to help him care for his mother, who was basically a vegetable for the past two and a half years but showed no sign of dying. But Cardiff had loved Tara deeply. He thought Monica was the person who had killed her.
The case seemed to be leading nowhere, and Rory's obsession with it was affecting his concentration on his tennis game. While Rory was trying to limber up, Don Floyd, an eighty-year-old tennis pro, noted that Rory was concentrating too hard on his first serve. He said, "Rory, when I can't ever get the first one in, I generally try to focus on the second service."
Bingo! The second service! Rory suddenly knew which of his three suspects was guilty...
An interesting story, but very flawed. First, we have to accept that the murderer was one of the three suspects, leaving out anyone else Tara might have met or blackmailed while building up her cash reserve, and that includes the anonymous "Frank" from the porno tape. Also, Monica was a heavy drug user, with track marks on her arms. She had worn a long-sleeved blouse when Rory had met her, so he didn't notice, but I find it hard to picture a stripper being able hide such track marks while performing. And, Rory's solution to the puzzle was just a guess, nothing more. He had to set a trap to be sure. And the denouement to the story was very unsatisfying, leaving Monica as the murderer in the eyes of the public, and not clearing her name -- which is what she had wanted Rory to do.
Basically, a by-the-numbers story that clearly shows that Healy expended his energy and talent far more his stories about John Francis Cuddy that Rory Calhoun. Is it still worth reading? Yeah, I think so, but just don't expect a Cuddy-like plot or experience.
Jeremiah Healey was an interesting character. He approached his writing career much like the lawyer he was, examining pros and cons and building a case from the ground up. He had researched the novel market and learned that some 70% of novels at the tine were bought by women so he deliberately shaped the Cuddy character to appeal to that market, while retaining many of the private eye tropes that have made the genre so popular. He attacked issues of the day, but not in a hardboiled manner -- more like soft-boiled with a hard edge. During interviews, he laid his many books in front of him, using them as props and evidence, picking each on up as he pointed out plots and themes in each; the attorney in him was selling his entire career and not just his latest release. As a law professor at the New England School of Law, he prided himself on being a hard-ass, wanting to push his students to be the very best they could be. Healy was personable, generous, and had a great sense of humor. I remember him taking newly published, first-time author Brendan DuBois aside and giving him useful career tips (DuBois, who was a talented writer from the start, went on to have a long career, publishing 29 novels, until his own personal demons derailed it in 2024); Healy also gave his time, support, and knowing advice to many other writers. He served as president of the Private Eye Writers of America (travelling the roads in his Volkswagon, dubbed "PWI-One") and the International Association of Crime Writers. I did not know him very well, but I liked him a lot. He survived a bout of prostate cancer in 2003 (about the time of the writing of "The Lady from Yesterday," which may have affected the quality of the story -- my speculation only). I was surprised and saddened when I learned that he had committed suicide at age 66 in 2014. He had evidently been suffering from depression, a disease that can destroy the best of us.
